The Confidence to Trust Yourself: What If the “Right” Strategy Is Wrong for You?

by | 25 Sep 2026

Last week, I cancelled something I’d already publicly said I was going to do.

I’d announced the masterclass.

Made the graphics.

Built the registration page.

Set up the emails.

Promoted it.

People had registered.

And then I cancelled the whole bloody thing.

Which was mildly irritating, given that I’m an Identity Designer who regularly tells people to do the damn thing.

So before I allowed myself to declare that I was trusting my intuition, I had to ask myself a much less comfortable question…

Am I cancelling this because it genuinely isn’t right for me, or am I cancelling because I’m scared?

Because there’s a huge difference in my opinion.

Sometimes “this doesn’t feel aligned” absolutely IS self-trust.

And sometimes it can also be avoidance with excellent branding.

And unfortunately, there isn’t a handy fucking flowchart that tells you which one you’re doing in the moment.

When the “right” strategy doesn’t feel right

There was nothing inherently wrong with the masterclass itself. In fact I loved what I’d prepared. It made complete commercial sense too.

Run a free masterclass.

Teach something useful.

Make an offer.

Invite people into The Identity EDIT™

People build enormously successful businesses using exactly that kind of launch model.

The problem really wasn’t the strategy.

The problem was that I didn’t want to build mine that way.

And when I stripped away the financial pressure and asked myself whether I’d still choose that route if I didn’t need it to make money, the answer was immediate.

No.

Absolutely not.

That didn’t make me question the work. Not at all that.

It made me question the route.

And those are actually very different.

Sometimes self-trust isn’t changing what you believe in.

It’s changing the way you’ve been told you’re supposed to get there.

When learning becomes copying

I’ve deliberately spent a significant amount of time and money learning from some amazingly brilliant people.

People who understand sales.

Marketing.

Events.

High-ticket offers.

Online business.

Launching.

Strategy.

I want to learn from people who know things I don’t.

But I’ve realised there’s a big distinction I’m becoming increasingly interested in:

At what point does learning from brilliant people subtly turn into abandoning your own knowing?

When does “What can I learn from this?” turn into “How do I make myself fit this?”

And this isn’t only about business. It’s life too.

Women are handed templates long before we’re old enough to even question them.

What a good girl does.

What success looks like.

What a good mother looks like.

What marriage should look like.

What financial security means.

What our bodies should look like.

How ambitious we’re allowed to be.

What women in their 40s, 50s or 60s are supposed to want.

When we’re supposed to settle down.

When we’re supposed to be grateful.

When we’re supposed to stop wanting more.

You can get really fucking good at creating a life according to a blueprint you never consciously chose.

And one day look around and think:

Is this actually mine?

Maybe we’ve misunderstood confidence

All of this sent me into yet another rabbit hole.

Confidence.

I feel like we tend to treat confidence almost like certainty.

Confident people know what they’re doing.

They walk into rooms like they own them.

They speak loudly.

They don’t get nervous.

They make decisions and KNOW they’ll work.

Except…

How the fuck could we know that?

We’re making decisions with incomplete information about a future that hasn’t happened yet.

So what if confidence isn’t:

“I know this will work.”

What if it’s:

“I trust myself even though I don’t know whether this will work.”

That’s different.

One requires certainty about the future. The other just needs a relationship with yourself.

Self-trust isn’t knowing you’ll get it right

I honestly don’t know whether cancelling that masterclass was commercially the right decision.

Maybe it would have been brilliant.

Maybe I’d have sold 20 places.

Maybe Future Sarah will look back and think:

You absolute dozy bitch! 

Self-trust doesn’t require me to pretend I know.

Instead….I trust myself to deal with what happens next.

I trust myself to notice when something isn’t working.

I trust myself to change direction.

I trust myself to ask for help.

I trust myself to learn.

I trust myself not to turn one unsuccessful decision into evidence that I am unsuccessful.

And I trust myself not to abandon myself simply because somebody else would have chosen differently.

That’s the confidence I want.

Not certainty.

Self-reliance.

Self-trust needs receipts

And this is where identity comes back in.

You don’t build self-trust by thinking really hard about trusting yourself.

Eventually, identity work has to leave the bloody journal and your head.

You build it through actual evidence.

You said you’d hold the boundary.

You did.

Receipt.

You said you’d quote the price.

You did.

Receipt.

You said you’d publish the thing even though somebody might judge you.

You did.

Receipt.

You asked for help instead of automatically saying, “I’m fine.”

Receipt.

You realised something you’d chosen no longer felt right and allowed yourself to change your mind.

Receipt.

Your old identity has years of evidence.

If you want a different relationship with yourself, you need to start creating new evidence.

And sometimes even changing your mind becomes another receipt for the woman you’re choosing to be.

So ask yourself this

Not: What’s the right decision?

You might not know.

Not: What would my mentor do?

Not: What would Instagram’s latest seven-figure CEO tell me to do?

Ask:

If I trusted myself, what would I do next?

No guarantee.

No certainty.

No requirement that everybody understands.

Just the next decision.

And then the next.

And another piece of evidence.

Because perhaps self-trust isn’t believing you’ll always make the right decision.

It’s knowing you won’t abandon yourself while you fucking make it.

And maybe that’s what confidence was supposed to mean all along.

Want to hear the full story?

In Episode 161 of The Reinvention Era, The Confidence to Trust Yourself: What happens when the “right” strategy is wrong for you?, I go deeper into the decision to cancel the masterclass, the business templates we unconsciously follow, belonging, identity and why changing your mind can sometimes be evidence of self-trust.

LISTEN TO EPISODE 161

Ready to close your own Identity Gap?

The Identity EDIT™ is my eight-week live identity implementation experience for women who already know what they want to change but keep watching the old identity make the decision when real life turns up.

We stop endlessly talking about Future Her and start creating evidence of her through real decisions, behaviours and Identity Experiments.

EXPLORE THE IDENTITY EDIT™

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sign up here

To get the latest posts & news straight to your inbox